Effective Strategies for Making Tough Decisions

Newton Neuropsychology Group • December 16, 2025

Share this article

Many sources suggest that individuals make up to 35,000 decisions a day!

Man with briefcase at a fork in the road, pondering. Directional sign with arrows, question mark overhead.

Overview



Many individuals struggle with decision-making. Fear of making the wrong decision, worries of having to deal with negative consequences from a bad decision, and having trouble navigating the swarming sea of pros and cons with decisions can make this everyday task much more daunting. In addition to personal factors, decision-making can often feel difficult as others may be affected by the choices we make, too. There can be so much uncertainty and complexity within each of these decisions, and with 35,000 a day, there is a lot of room for indecisiveness! 


Many individuals describe themselves as “indecisive.” Others view many of the decisions they make as not requiring much thought. And most people will fall somewhere between these two along this lengthy spectrum!


How is the brain involved in decision making?


There are a few areas of the brain that are involved in decision-making. The prefrontal cortex, for example, evaluates and judges potential options. The lateral prefrontal lobe calculates the outcomes of various choices during decision-making. Additionally, the ventral striatum weighs the pros and cons of various decisions and the steps required to follow through. Many additional areas of the brain are involved. 


Neurotransmitters, the chemicals that help send messages in the brain, are also involved in the decision-making process. For example, when dopamine is released, decisions are often made faster. However, this speed increase in decision-making can sometimes lead to more inaccurate or effective choices. Serotonin can also change our decisions because it affects positive reward signals and motivation.


Adrenaline can also impede decision-making. If you ever recall a moment when you felt under pressure or stressed, and it was harder to think clearly, adrenaline is largely to blame. As heart rate and blood pressure increase with stress, and cortisol levels may skyrocket, making decisions can feel more challenging with your body in “fight or flight.” Acetylcholine is also essential in decision-making motor actions. Finally, many mental tasks require focus and attention, which can cause glutamate to build up. If there is too much glutamate, the lateral prefrontal cortex can have trouble making decisions! 



What strategies can we implement?


There are many things that we can do to help make decision-making just a little bit easier :) 


  1. Define clear goals and set deadlines 
  2. Gather relevant information
  3. List possible options and weigh the pros and cons 
  4. Seek help from others
  5. Think about the short-term AND long-term implications of these decisions 
  6. And think about the past, too - what can you learn from past decisions? 
  7. Use your heart and your brain. Go with rationale and your gut. 
  8. Reduce stress levels and find moments of self-care 
  9. Adequate sleep and fueling yourself is essential! 
  10. Incorporate scaffolding. Break decisions into smaller steps 
  11. Limit distractions and take breaks 
  12. Foster a positive mood. You got this :) 


In Conclusion…


Decision-making can feel very tricky. We may feel that we don’t have enough control over the process or that no outcome feels “perfect.” In these moments, it is critical to take a step back, tell yourself you got this, seek help from others, and find moments of self-care. You can do this! 



Sources


https://hbr.org/2023/12/a-simple-way-to-make-better-decisions#:~:text=Various%20sources%20suggest%20that%20the,how%20we'll%20say%20it. 


https://effectiviology.com/why-its-hard-to-make-decisions/ 


https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-creativity-cure/201408/why-is-it-difficult-make-decisions#:~:text=Indecision%20can%20also%20stem%20from,of%20hurting%20or%20alienating%20another.


https://www.inc.com/jeff-haden/neuroscience-says-making-a-few-simple-changes-to-your-work-day-will-help-you-make-smarter-decisions-be-more-productive.html#:~:text=Difficult%20mental%20tasks%20that%20require,planning)%20in%20a%20significant%20way


https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2023/09/230919154839.htm#:~:text=A%20recent%20study%20provides%20new,tend%20to%20be%20more%20inaccurate. 


https://www.nature.com/articles/npp2010165#:~:text=Finally%2C%20while%20serotonin%20may%20modulate,with%20the%20evidence%20of%20functional 


Recent Posts

November 12, 2026
Understand the difference between normal age-related memory changes and possible dementia symptoms, and learn when to consider a cognitive evaluation.
 autism evaluations
By Jason Alan • November 11, 2026
Learn what to expect from a fast-track autism evaluation for young children, including early signs, assessment steps, and support options for families.
September 2, 2026
Heading back to school can create so many big feelings from anxiety to excitement.
By Dr. Christina Lin • August 28, 2026
The transition from fluid, fun-filled summer to the structured rhythm of the school year can feel like a jolt to the system, for both kids and parents. Moving from late nights and sleeping in to early alarms and homework requires more than just buying new school supplies. It requires an intentional shift in your household’s daily rhythms. By establishing routines early, fostering collaboration, and balancing structure with flexibility, you can set your child up for a successful, lower-stress school year. Here is a guide on how to navigate this transition smoothly! 1. Start Early and Collaborate (Create “Buy-In”) The golden rule of school transitions is to prepare ahead of time! Starting to shift your family’s schedule a week or two before the first bell rings will make the actual first week of school feel like a breeze rather than a shock to the system. To make this transition easier, involve your child in the planning process. When children have a say in their routine, they develop a sense of ownership and are far more likely to cooperate. How to collaborate: Sit down together and co-create the daily schedule. Offer a few, structured choices to create buy-in. For example, ask: “Would you rather pack your backpack before dinner or right before bed?” or “Do you want to pick out your outfit for the next day, or should we do it together?” Establish non-negotiables: While collaboration is key, parents must set the boundaries. Clearly define the non-negotiables upfront, such as weekly screen time limits. Knowing the firm boundaries makes the flexible areas easier to negotiate. 2. Master the Bedtime Routine to Save Your Mornings A successful morning is won the night before. If your child is sleep-deprived, the morning routine will inevitably become a battleground. The Incremental Shift: Gradually move bedtime and wake-up times earlier by short increments (about 15-20 minutes) every few days until you reach the target school-year schedule. The “Wind-Down” Ritual: Transitioning the brain from high energy to sleep takes time. Implement a consistent, screen-free wind-down routine. This might include a warm bath, reading together, or listening to quiet music. Morning Prep Before Bed: Eliminate morning decision fatigue! Make it a rule that tomorrow’s breakfast is decided, backpacks are packed, shoes are by the door, and outfits are laid out the night before. 3. Prioritize After-School Decompression The end of the school day is a critical transition point. Kids spend all day holding in their energy, managing emotions, and following strict rules. When they get home, they often experience “after-school restraint collapse.” To prevent meltdowns, build in dedicated decompression time: The Silent Car Ride: Sometimes, the best greeting is silence. Give your child permission to have a quiet ride home without immediately asking, “How was your day?” Let them initiate the conversation when they are ready. The Immediate Snack: Low blood sugar is the enemy of cooperation. Meet your child at the door or in the car with a nutritious, filling snack to recharge their physical battery immediately. Move the Body: Before asking them to sit down for homework, let them release pent-up physical energy. Dedicate 20–30 minutes after school (or right after dinner) for outdoor play, riding a bike, or a family walk. Clearing the mind physically makes it much easier to focus mentally later. 4. Practice “Flexible Consistency” Consistency is the foundation of security for children, but rigidity can breed anxiety. Aim for flexible consistency . Stick to your routines as closely as possible, but recognize when your child is genuinely exhausted, overwhelmed, or needs a break. If a Tuesday night homework session is met with tears and extreme fatigue, it is okay to pivot, allow an early bedtime, and tackle the work in the morning or communicate with the teacher. By starting early, offering choices, and prioritizing rest and decompression, you aren’t just surviving the back-to-school transition, you are teaching your child valuable life skills in time management, self-regulation, and balance. 5. Ease Into “Brain Work” During the summer, cognitive demands look very different. Expecting a child to immediately transition to focusing for six hours a day can lead to mental fatigue and frustration. In the week leading up to school, start reintroducing structured cognitive activities. This doesn’t mean worksheets; instead, encourage 20–30 minutes of sustained reading, playing board games that require strategy, or working on puzzles. This helps rebuild the “focus stamina” they will need in the classroom.
August 25, 2026
The transition from relaxing summer to a fixed school schedule can be difficult, especially for kids with executive functioning challenges. With increasing demands, students need to plan more and procrastinate less. You may be wondering what you can do to make this transition smoother for your kids. We have some tips!
Dr.Burns in graduation cap and gown sitting with two dogs on grass by a tree, all smiling.
By Rachel Kimball • June 30, 2026
Learn more about Dr. Burns, one of our amazing clinicians here at Newton Neuro. Neuropsychological testing for children and adults in greater Boston. ADHD, autism, learning disorders, and therapy services.
Child using behavioral therapy techniques for ADHD management at Newton Neuro Psychology Group
By Jessica Gashin • February 27, 2026
Learn about evidence-based ADHD treatments and effective therapy methods that truly make a difference. Start your journey towards better focus and emotional well-being today.
Three types of ADHD with symptom comparisons explained by Newton Neuropsychology Group
By Jessica Gashin • February 25, 2026
Learn about the three main types of ADHD including inattentive, hyperactive-impulsive, and combined types. Understand symptoms at Newton Neuro.
Silhouette head with paper brain,
By Jessica Gashin • February 17, 2026
Discover common ADHD symptoms in adults including inattention, impulsivity, and hyperactivity. Learn when to seek testing from Newton Neuropsychology Group in MA
Professional neuropsychologist reviewing evaluation materials in Newton MA office
By Jessica Gashin • February 11, 2026
Learn about the costs associated with neuropsychological testing, including what factors to consider when budgeting for these essential evaluations.
Show More